有个小伙伴问有没有大修意见(Major Revision)的模板,我的第一反应是大修哪还有什么模板啊,就是一条一条的回复审稿人的修改建议啊。不过后来翻了翻自己以前写的回复信,发现多多少少还是有一定模板性的,尤其是对于第一次遇到这种情况的研究生朋友们,可以先从模板开始熟悉一下此类回复信的大体内容和形式。
模板1:精简版本 下面这个是小编自己以前写的一个模板,拿出来分享给大家。 模板2: 完整版本 这个模板是我在网上找到的,经发布者授权,转载到这里。这个模板保留了很多逐条回答审稿人的常用短语和句式,值得收藏和学习! Dear Editor, Dear reviewers
Thanks again!
Your response to the general comments from the editor
接下来是逐条回应审稿人的建议:
Reviewer #1:
Response to the questions one by one
Reviewer #2:
Response to the questions one by one
Thank you for your letter dated February 22. We were pleased to know that our work was rated as potentially acceptable for publication in Journal, subject to adequate revision. We thank the reviewers for the time and effort that they have put into reviewing the previous version of the manuscript. Their suggestions have enabled us to improve our work. Based on the instructions provided in your letter, we uploaded the file of the revised manuscript. Accordingly, we have uploaded a copy of the original manuscript with all the changes highlighted by using the track changes mode in MS Word.
Appended to this letter is our point-by-point response to the comments raised by the reviewers. The comments are reproduced and our responses are given directly afterward in a different color (red).
We would like also to thank you for allowing us to resubmit a revised copy of the manuscript.
We hope that the revised manuscript is accepted for publication in the Journal of Mountain Science.
Sincerely,
XXXXXXX
Reviewer 1:
Comments to the Author
Here are the general comments from the reviewer...
We thank the reviewer for the very interesting comments. In fact…
Minor comments:
The title is too long, I suggest shortening.
Line 25, page 1…
Modified throughout the text according to the comment (Line 20, page 1).
Line 18, page 2…
Line 33, page 3…
Thank you for underlining this deficiency. This section was revised and modified according to the information showed in the work suggested by the reviewer (Line 41, page 3).
Line 59, page 5…
This phrase was modified according to the comment (Line 30, page 5).
Lines 9-24, page 6…
Line 11, page 6…
This sentence was rephrased according to the comment (Line 8, page 6).
We have modified this expression throughout the text according to the comment.